Auto Insurance

When Should You Switch Auto Insurance Companies?

Dylan Saatdjian

Written by Dylan Saatdjian

Insurance Expert

December 6, 2025 5 min read
A man celebrates a successful online purchase, holding a credit card near a laptop in an office setting. He is joyful.

Staying with the same auto insurance company for years might seem convenient, but it could be costing you hundreds of dollars annually. Knowing when to shop around and switch carriers is one of the smartest financial moves Nevada drivers can make.

Here are the key signs it's time to compare rates and consider switching to a new auto insurance provider.

7 Signs It's Time to Switch Auto Insurance

SIGN #1

Your Rates Increased Significantly at Renewal

If your premium jumped 10% or more at renewal—and you haven't filed claims or had violations—it's a red flag. Insurance companies regularly adjust rates, but you don't have to accept steep increases without shopping around.

What to do:

Get quotes from at least 3 other carriers. You might find the same coverage for 20-30% less with a different company.

SIGN #2

It's Been More Than 2 Years Since You Last Compared

Insurance rates change constantly based on market conditions, your demographics, and competitive factors. What was the best rate 3 years ago might not be today.

Recommended

Shop rates every 1-2 years

Best Practice

Compare at every renewal

SIGN #3

Your Life Situation Has Changed

Major life changes often qualify you for better rates or different discounts. Your current insurer might not automatically adjust your premium to reflect these changes.

Life Changes That Impact Rates:

Got married
Bought a home
Improved credit score
Changed jobs/commute
Teen driver moved out
Retired or work from home
SIGN #4

You're Unhappy with Customer Service

Poor customer service, difficulty filing claims, or unresponsive agents are valid reasons to switch. You deserve an insurance company that values your business.

Red flags: Long hold times, denied reasonable claims, unclear policy explanations, no local agent support

Look for: Local agents, 24/7 support, mobile app with easy claims filing, good online reviews

SIGN #5

You Can Bundle and Save with Another Carrier

If you have auto and home (or renters) insurance with different companies, you're likely missing out on significant multi-policy discounts.

Bundle Savings Example

Separate Companies

$2,400

per year combined

Bundled Together

$1,800

Save $600/year (25%)

SIGN #6

You're Not Getting Discounts You Qualify For

Not all insurance companies offer the same discounts. If your current insurer doesn't provide discounts you qualify for, another carrier might.

Good Student

Low Mileage

Usage-Based

SIGN #7

Your Accident or Violation Is About to Fall Off Your Record

Most accidents and violations affect your rates for 3-5 years. Once they're removed from your record, you should qualify for lower rates—but your current insurer might not automatically reduce your premium.

When Incidents Fall Off:

Minor violations (speeding) 3 years
At-fault accidents 3-5 years
DUI/major violations 5-10 years

How to Switch Auto Insurance Smoothly

Switching insurance companies is easier than most people think. Follow these steps to ensure a seamless transition without coverage gaps.

1

Get Multiple Quotes

Compare rates from at least 3-5 carriers. Make sure you're comparing identical coverage limits and deductibles for accurate results.

2

Choose Your New Policy Start Date

Schedule your new policy to start on the same day your current policy ends. This prevents coverage gaps and avoids paying for two policies simultaneously.

💡 Tip: Most policies renew every 6 months, making renewal time the perfect opportunity to switch.

3

Purchase Your New Policy

Once you've found better coverage at a lower price, purchase your new policy. You'll receive proof of insurance immediately.

4

Cancel Your Old Policy

Contact your old insurer to cancel effective on your new policy start date. Don't cancel before your new policy is active!

⚠️ Important: Get cancellation confirmation in writing. Most insurers will refund any unused premium.

5

Update Your Auto Loan or Lease Company

If you finance or lease your vehicle, send your new proof of insurance to your lender to keep your account in good standing.

When You Might Want to Stay Put

You have a pending claim: Wait until it's settled to avoid complications

Loyalty discounts kick in soon: Some insurers offer significant discounts after 3-5 years

You'd lose accident forgiveness: If you have a claim pending forgiveness, it might not transfer

Savings are minimal: If the difference is less than $100/year, convenience might outweigh savings

The Bottom Line

There's no single "right time" to switch auto insurance—it depends on your individual situation. However, Nevada drivers who compare rates regularly and switch when it makes financial sense save an average of $500-1,000 per year.

Don't let loyalty cost you hundreds of dollars. Take 15 minutes to compare rates, and you might discover significant savings waiting for you.

Ready to Compare Rates?

See if you can save hundreds on auto insurance in just minutes.

Share this article: